HarvestH2o Online Community



PRIVACY: We will not sell, rent or share your name with anyone. see policy





Rainwater System Component Articles

Sample Systems

Water Conservation Articles

Water Quality Articles

Water Op Eds:

Is Rainwater Really Safe - One Sample Case
by Doug Pushard

Water quality is an extremely hot topic these days. With continued population growth and strained water supplies it is likely to become even more so. It is estimated that already one in five homes have some type of water filtration or purification system installed. The bottled water industry is also experiencing a boom. Water quality concerns are probably a factor driving growth of rainwater harvesting as well.

But little information is readily available on the quality of rain water. Consequently, it is difficult to understand what the real issues may be and then make decisions on what type of treatment system to install, if any. Claims by manufacturers of various products trying to hawk wares definitely have a point of view. So it is a period of “caveat emptor - let the buyer beware”, in trying to figure out what to do.

So the question remains - Is rainwater safe? To shed light on the issue, I performed a set of water quality tests. Water from a cistern and an adjacent well in Lamy, New Mexico were tested. Additionally, I compared these samples to city water from my new home city of Santa Fe, New Mexico.

A Few Key Water Quality Metrics

pH - The measure of the water's relative acidity or alkalinity. A pH of 7 is neutral while higher numbers indicate acidity and lower alkalinity.

Conductivity - A measure of how well the water conducts electricity. This gives an indication of ion concentration in the water sample.

Turbidity - Measures the impedance of light through water. The particles which cause turbidity can interfere with disinfection by sheltering microbes; thereby enabling bacteria to survive UV sterilization, for example.

Hardness - Hardness is caused by calcium and high levels of magnesium salts and inhibits the cleaning action of soaps and detergents. It can also cause deposits of scale on the inside of hot water pipes and cooking utensils.

Total Suspended Solids (TSS) - are undissolved particles ranging in size from a pine needle to a single-cell

eColiform Colony Count - Indicator organisms (such as Escherichis coli) are used as a proxy for the presence of specific disease-causing organisms like Salmonella typhi.

Water was drawn directly from the cistern and well (i.e. prior to any treatment) on the same day and sent to the National Testing Laboratories to be tested in accordance to their procedures. These samples I then compared to Santa Fe’s published Water Quality report. Most water districts publish this information as it is required by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

Comparing the cistern water to the well water, it is clear that cistern water is better or equal to the well water; except that the cistern has a presence of coliform. Coliform, a bacteria, is frequently found in streams, lakes, ponds, cisterns; and may indicate the water is contaminated with other harmful bacteria. Systems used for drinking water should always have some type of sterilization process (See related article on UV Sterilization of Rainwater Catchment Systems) to kill bacteria and organisms such as coliform.

Not so surprisingly there is a huge difference in hardness, calcium, and alkalinity between the well water and the rainwater. Well water typically drains from underground water tables and is normally stored in natural underground tanks; so it will slowly leach minerals and metals from the surrounding ground. Consequently, well water will generally have higher mineral and metal content depending on local soil conditions. In comparison, rain water will not have these issues, but may be adversely affected by local air pollution and debris in the rainwater catchment and conveyance areas (i.e. roof, gutters, downspouts, and pipes).

In the table below, the best (i.e. lowest) rating is in GREEN and the highest rating in RED. This, of course, assumes you don’t want your metals and minerals coming from your tap water. As can be seen from this comparison, rainwater is at the lowest end for most of the tests. Limited air pollution in the Lamy area likely positively impacts the high quality of the harvested rain.



  Cistern Well City
18.6 - 532
Total Dissolved Solids*
130 - 884
.014 - .21
0 - 27.48
<.01 - .063
0 - .107
0 - .046
7.1 - 8.0
<.02 - <.05
0 - 31
<.02 - .058

(0) zero denotes none present, NA means not reported and * means milligrams of substance per liter of water. It is important to note, none of the tests exceeded the Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCL) as set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) except for the presence of Coliform.

Both well and cistern results were surprisingly good in comparison compared to the Santa Fe municipal water. Santa Fe gets its water from a range of sources. Included in the table are the low and high readings from the various sources as reported in the 2004 Water Quality report published in the first half of 2005. Santa Fe tap water will typically be a mixture of the water sources and consequently be a blending of the levels reported above.

In this comparison, the city water was absolutely highest in Total Dissolved Solids, aluminum, chloride, iron, manganese, and silver. The city water, from at least one source, also had the highest hardness. In all the tests where data was reported the city water was only lower in one category – zinc. Remember all the data reported above is prior to treatment and consequently most of these are taken out or greatly reduced by the city prior to being delivered to the tap (i.e. through chemicals and my tax dollars at work).

In this admittedly highly limited test, rain water faired impressively well against both well and municipal water supplies. It had lower pH, hardness and mineral content; consequently, it should cause less scale build up in pipes and cooking utensils; suds up better in the shower; and probably taste better. But the rain water did have coliform present which can be a health hazard and always needs to be treated.

To reduce the probability of coliform in rainwater harvesting systems and wells the following steps are highly recommended:

  1. Always keep the rain catchment clean and free of debris
  2. Trim trees and brushes near the area to prevent animals from entering the storage tanks
  3. Keep water storage tanks shaded and use non-transparent tanks to prevent sunlight from fostering bacteria growth
  4. If the water is to be used for drinking, always use some type treatment system (e.g. UV sterilization) to deal with the potential bacteria.

As can be seen in this small sample, rainwater can actually be better than tap water, but always be safe - test it before you use it!


Related Info - Sample water quality report
Related Info - EPA published water standards
Related Article - UV Lamps
Related Article - Using a UV Lamp in a Rainwater Catchment System
Related Article - Simple sand filter for water purification
Related Info - Santa Fe Water Quality reports (under E-Library)
Related Info - Santa Fe Water Quality report used in article
Related Webpage - Vendors of water filtration systems
Related Webpage - EPA - Protecting Drinking Water
Related Book - Drinking Water Book - How to Filter Your Water





February 2015

Lawns v oysters

Portland is now powered by water pipes and flushing toilets

U.S. 'Megadroughts' Are Likely Later This Century, Study Finds

New Dangers Found In Produced Water

Florida's Water Waste Prompts Look at Recyling

Dirty California Water Linked To Obesity

Researchers Call For Changes In 50-Year-Old Drinking Water Standards

January 2015

Onwards to a future of grey and black water

Rain, rain, don't go away

First Ever Performance-Based Comparative Water Use Rating Tool for Home Builders

Big Fracking Question: Is Our Drinking Water at Risk

New SWIFT fund will pump millions into water projects in Texas

Water plan tackles critical issue of supply and demand

Reclaimed Water May Cut Need for Fertilizer

National – States React to New Era of Water Scarcity

December 2014

Mexico City In Crisis Over Water

Next Step in Sustainability: Requiring Homes to Recycle Water

Plan to Connect Storm Water Drains to Water Bodies in City

November 2014

St. Paul Saints ballpark equipped with RWH system

Oklahoma Approves Water Reuse Law

Colorado Takes On Looming Water Shortages

Hydrology hypotheses: can we make our own water?

Mexico City faces growing water crisis

October 2014

Recycled Water For Irrigation — Is It Safe?

In Times of Drought: Nine Economic Facts about Water in the United States

Santa Cruz Enforces California's Toughest Drought Restrictions

San Antonio has options better than Vista Ridge Pipeline

The Risks of Cheap Water

The Real Relationship Between Conservation and Rising Water Rates

Could Water Scarcity Prompt A Battle Between U.S. and Canada?

Once-vast Aral Sea dries up to almost nothing

With Dry Taps and Toilets, California Drought Turns Desperate

September 2014

Federal Report: EPA Fracking Oversight Not Enough

Into The Storm: Forecasting The Future Of Water

Think the Southwest’s Drought Is Bad Now? It Could Last a Generation or More

Water Shortages Strike Another State

Are Fracking Chemicals Getting Too Close To Drinking Water Aquifers?

August 2014

Satellites Show Major Southwest Groundwater Loss

July 2014

Storms Get Headlines, but Drought Is a Sneaky, Devastating Game-Changer

Saving Water in California

Waste Not, Want Not

June 2014

First Ever Long-Term Rebate Study

Arizona Cities Could Face Cutbacks in Water From Colorado River, Officials Say

Home Water Management Using Rain Barrels

May 2014

A Postmodern Water Frontier

April 2014

Five Melbourne companies guzzle water

Drought Defense

Time to finally protect wetlands, streams

Texas Wins Advantage In Groundwater Fight With New Mexico

Texas Water Rules Are A Mess

March 2014

Water crisis in the twilight zone

The Thirsty West: What Happens in Vegas Doesn’t Stay in Vegas

West’s Drought and Growth Intensify Conflict Over Water Rights

New Indirect Potable Reuse Regulations — What To Expect

The Thirsty West: Can Tucson Survive Climate Change?

Conserve and Get a Smiley Face

February 2014

Days of Desiccation

EPA Releases Climate Assessment Update To National Stormwater Calculator

California Seeing Brown Where Green Used to Be

Malta needs 'national watermanagement plan

Severe Drought Has U.S. West Fearing Worst

Parched, California Cuts Off Tap to Agencies

January 2014

Its Great Lake Shriveled, Iran Confronts Crisis of Water Supply

EPA Announce Science Research Grants

3 Tips For Utilities On Effective Consumer Outreach

EPA Stormwater Ruling: How Will It Impact Utilities?

Spending Bill Includes Over $2 Billion For State Water Funds

California areas brace for water rationing as reservoir levels fall

Chemical levels in West Virginia water drop, but still no end in sight to ban

EPA's Top 10 Technology Needs For Water

Lead In D.C. Water Associated With Miscarriages

Is This the Future of RO

Old Water News >>


List a Workshop

Webinar: Water Conservation Rebates: The Santa Fe Experience


Xerxes Tanks

Rain Harvesting Systems


Fun Facts


  1. How do you harvest rainwater?
  2. Where do you get the water?
  3. What is the best way of harvesting rain?
  4. Why should I harvest rainwater?
  5. Do I need pumps to harvest rainwater?
  6. Can I use drip irrigation or soaker hoses with a rainwater?
  7. How big a yard can I water?
  8. How big are rain barrels?
  9. I want more pressure, how should I raise it?
  10. Can I water my grass with rainwater?

    and many more>>
Favorite Water Books

Taking on Water

A Great Aridness

Drinking Water

Tapped Out



Copyright © 1990-2015 HarvestH2o, All Rights Reserved 505-603-5498